RCMP officer says his interrogation of sex assault victim was not improper

Editor’s Note: APTN News originally reported that the RCMP filed a statement of defence when in fact it was Cpl. Kent Hall filing it on his own behalf.

An RCMP officer in B.C. says his conduct during the interrogation of a female youth who went to police to complain of being sexually assaulted was not improper.

According to a response filed in a B.C. court, Cpl. Kent Hall, the officer being sued by the woman he interviewed during a sexual assault report, said he “conducted the interview in a proper manner,” according to his response filed on July 8, 2019.

In the interview, first reported by APTN News, Hall asked a series of questions to the youth who was in care at the time.

“Were you at all turned on during this at all? Even a little bit?” Hall said to her in one part of the more than two hour video of the interview. “You understand that when a guy tries to have sex with a female and the female is completely unwilling it is very difficult.”

Read More:

‘Were you turned on by this at all?’: RCMP officer asks Indigenous youth during sexual assault report 

RCMP officer in sex assault interrogation video sued for punitive damages

Lawyer for woman in extremely aggressive RCMP video says client was ‘disbelieved from the beginning’

B.C. social worker accused of punishing Indigenous youth for sexual assault while in foster care 

The video surfaced as part of a civil suit against the Ministry of Children and Family Development and individual social workers.

More than a dozen Indigenous youth had their funds siphoned off by social worker Robert Riley Saunders.

The ministry has admitted vicarious liability for the scheme.

Hall “denies each and every allegation of fact” contained in the woman’s civil suit.

The statement denies “any act, omission, negligence, breach of duty, statutory or otherwise, on the part of Cpl. Hall.”


(Cpl. Kent Hall, centre, says he “conducted the interview in a proper manner.” Photo: B.C. government) 

The woman, who APTN has previously identified as ‘J’ filed a  lawsuit last month claiming  her charter rights were violated because she was actually brought into the detachment on suspicion of public mischief, not to report a sexual assault.

Hall’s response claims she was “never detained, nor was the Plaintiff ever facing any legal jeopardy during the course of the interview. During the interview, the Plaintiff was told she was allowed to leave at any time.”

“Put simply, the Plaintiff’s section 9 and section 10 charter rights were never engaged,” according to the statement filed in court.

General occurrence reports obtained by APTN show that the woman was brought into the detachment on suspicion of public mischief for lying about the assault. She was not charged but ordered to participate in a restorative justice program.

She said that process included a requirement to write letters of apology to her foster parents and her social worker according to a March 2019 civil suit brought against the Ministry of Children and Family Development.

The response also stated the limitation period “expired sometime in 2015 or 2016” and “this claim cannot be brought” as a result of the expiration.

‘J’ is also seeking punitive damages in the civil suit for severe post-traumatic stress disorder, reduced earning capability, suicidal thoughts and emotional anguish. The claim also said Hall knew or should have known his behaviour would harm, offend, belittle, demean, threaten and humiliate her.

“The actions of Hall, the RCMP, were reckless, arrogant, high-handed and abusive and showed a callous disregard for the Plaintiff’s rights,” the claim said.

“Hall and the RCMP have engaged in conduct that is reprehensible and deserves punishment. The Plaintiff therefore, seeks punitive and exemplary damages against the Defendants.”

Hall’s response states “there is no basis for punitive damages,” as those are only awarded in exceptional circumstances.

“The proper conducting of a police interview for investigatory purposes does not meet this high threshold.”


Show Producer / Winnipeg

Holly Moore is an investigative journalist with 16 years of experience working on news and documentaries. Before joining APTN in 2016, she was an Associate Producer with CBC Manitoba’s I-team where she produced nation-wide projects for CBC’s Indigenous Unit. Her work has been nominated for a number of national awards, most recently by the Canadian Association of Journalists. An expert in deep research and never giving up, she strives through her work to hold powerful forces to account.